Case study – history of women in comics

This topic came to my mind during school tutorials, regarding my project. I was describing personality of my character and how it affects her appearance. My explanations weren’t sufficient for my tutor and one question kept flowing out of his mouth “Why does she look so sensual?”. I kept telling this is my style of drawing, which is based on a comic books style and for this character, goading clothes are sign of the rebellion and self assurance. That were good reasons for me but not for a tutor, the answer was: “Why”. I went home with the same question clouding in mind, thinking of the answer. Why does she look that way? I kept asking myself - Because she’s representing an archetype of a strong woman; Why is she sexy? – Because it’s a comic book style; Why is it typical for comic books? -------------I don’t know? But I will find out. That was the trail I walked to wake up the curiosity and desire to explore topics. I was really curious about the answer and actually, I spotted very interesting facts.

Evolution of women in comics


 In so called “Golden Era” of comics, outstretching from 1930s to 1940s, artists let their imagination free. There were various topic talked about, coming out as comics. Women were also included but, if appeared in a story, they were visualized rather as secondary roles, supporting the main character’s performance. 





 










There were some heroines, usually connected somehow to the male, main character superhero and mainly as lovers or girlfriends.  Fitting the secondary role, female figures and their costumes had nothing unusual in a design. They were not supposed to attract that much attention, as their role was just to accompany.

That was at the beginning, but historical facts had it’s mark left in mentality of people.

Historical influence

After World War II another types of personality started to be promoted. Women who had to work and support male fighting in a field, couldn’t expect help from anyone but themselves. It had a global aspect, women were encouraged to work in a factories, supplying heavy industry. It was time when all men were involved in fighting a war and with shortage of human source, authorities decided to involve both genders  in a play. I had a chance to research this topic a little bit, while visiting Museum of Transport in Coventry. There was an additional exhibition, presenting work in industries during World War II. Some points were dedicated the work of females, who supported factories, replacing men on their jobs. 



The new mentality was born and women started to feel their price and abilities. They were not only predicted to procreation and housekeeping but could serve higher purposes as well. It created some bases for feminism, women started to fight for their rights. This phenomenon, visible in society, had an impact on creation of female characters in comics. 









First superheroines

New type of women, gave the artists an idea for creating female characters for their comics. As the author of an article “Role of women in comics” said “This…..created the ‘femme fatale’, who was a sexually aggressive woman.” Looking at dictionary definition of “femme fatale”, it describes type of woman who’s using her position in society or personal attributes to use males, with harm for them. For this definition definitely has negative meaning, it doesn’t mean all superheroines are bad. As we can see on example of first Wonder Woman creation, she is the symbol of good. I would say, the same attributes used in service of evil can be used for purposes of goodness as well. The only thing that changes are enemies. In other words, we can have very attractive woman, who’s the positive character, and who uses her attributes to defeat evil.  Wonder Woman  was one of the first ever heroines who gained bigger attention of the audience and she was created by William Moulton Marston.

It was unusual in comics to give superpowers to a woman and let her play  a leading role in a story, while only male had those abilities before.  The best explanation for this character is given by it’s creator: "America's woman of tomorrow should be made the hero of a new type of comic strip. By this, I mean a character with all the allure of an attractive woman, but with the strength also of a powerful man. There isn't enough love in the male organism to run this planet peacefully. What women presently lack is the dominance or self-assertive power to put over and enforce her love diaries. I have given Wonder Woman this dominant force, but kept her loving. It is my hope to make this strip as appealing to adults as it has proved to kids.”


Although a superhero, Wonder Woman was always showed bounded. Specialists explain that it could have a symbolic meaning of achieving freedom, the feminist equal rights. But facing the truth, for readers it was understood as sexual aspect. Also her costume design was different to her predecessors. It’s form emphasized female shape but wasn’t much revealing and could be described as a good taste. 
 



 


Changes in comics industry

Comics developed in 30’s and 40’s and people had some freedom of self expression.  Unfortunately, authorities felt that some things are getting too far. Comics always had to deal with some restrictions, but there was time, when situation got really tense. Dr. Fredric Wertham  was a psychiatrist who researched dependence between environment’s influences and tendency to criminal behavior among young people. The final hit came in 1954 with releasing a book “Seduction of Innocent” where it’s author proved that comic books are filled with sex, crime, murder, sadism and other unacceptable actions and have a negative influence on the young age readers. 


Comic publishers had to rescue their companies and, in cooperation, in 1954 set up a Comic Code Authority (CCA). It had very strict and clear rules regarding content of comics: no
“ profanity, obscenity, smut, vulgarity, or words or symbols, that have acquired undesirable meanings….., vampires and vampirism, ghouls, cannibalism, and werewolfism, …….., nudity in any form is prohibited, as is indecent or undue exposure, …….. suggestive and salacious illustration or suggestive posture is unacceptable.”  
These were rules the companies had to follow if they still willed to publish. Each magazine had to have a sticker of approval and without it, there was no chances of publishing, selling and storing. 

Underground

As we know, people don’t like any restrictions limiting their rights and  forbidden ground always brings much more joy. The same thing happened with comics. Artists who didn’t follow the rules, still created their own stories but in hideout. It was gaining popularity, even though considered as illegal.
 

Revolution

In 1960’s situation started changing. Artists who worked in the underground brought out all “taboo” topics and set up their own networks and publishing companies. Period from 1960 to 1980 was time, when Comic Code started collapsing. Private publishers grown very successful, going over the restrictions. It wouldn’t work out without customers. People were hungry of things that were forbidden for so long, and as it usually happens, when you loose dog from the leash, the need for new prohibited stuff grow really fast. 

 







Until 1960’s, female characters showed up in comics just as a supporting role for the main male character. They played role of a lover or heart breaker. Due to restrictions, female figure was drawn “natural” without any exaggeration. It was made on a purpose, as to avoid restricted topics. In 60’s and 70’s, when revolution slowly started, artists tried to give more important role to females and turn them into heroines, like Sue - The Invisible Girl . 
She was treated as not strong enough and her role was mainly to meddle in romance story. But she was part of the team and female position started growing. So far female characters weren’t popular enough to perform alone, they were always a visiting roles in a main comics. 

 




 In 1979 a Black cat showed up for the first time in The Amazing Spiderman comic. She was a stronger female character than her predecessors and her suit design is based on a cat look, what brings more sexual thoughts to mind. These were the stages when female posture started changing.  










In 1980’s Female characters developed and evolved to the strong image and self stating heroines, finally. They were given more wisdom, more self assurance and most importantly the powers as strong as their male colleagues.
From that moment on, female figure started changing rapidly. That was the result of upgrading women position in comics but also reflection of a changing world. Sexuality has always been part of human being ,but was treated quite secretly and personal. For many years it was a topic of taboo, something what shouldn’t be talked about. The best example for that is the Comic Code and it’s restrictions.
As time past, more topics become acceptable and free to talk about, and nowadays, sexuality is something common and most attracting attention. That’s why comic books now look this way.

Bettie Page 1950
Another reason is different perception of beauty. For example, Bettie Page, who was a famous model back in 50’s, was considered as very attractive and Dave Stevens (comic artist) used her appearance as base for the character in Rocketeer. Nowadays different styles are promoted as attractive and artists change styles of drawing to gather bigger audience. 

Mila Kunis 2013






 






 






 

Another reason explaining current look of female characters is their promotion to the superheroines. Once that happened, the changes had to made to make them fit other characters. All male characters in DC and Marvel comic are stylized onto idyllic gods of perfection and their bodies grow to enormous shapes. This is all part of exaggeration to make those “super” figures flawless. Automatic response goes to female bodies. All attributes considered as feminine gain on sizes and shapes. To expose those features, females are drawn in very flexible, cat – like positions, just to make them perfect and attractive.
 








 As we can see, in comparison to previous years , heroines costumes changed as well. They got more revealing with years, and the less covered character became better. That’s another connection to times we’re living in. Nudity and skimpy clothes are promoted in each media, round every corner and as much as we would like to deny it, it is simply true. That’s something which attracts attention easily and bigger audience means bigger sell for comic books. It’s not for the artists but for the customers. Just don’t understand me wrong, I don’t mean to promote nudity, I just point out the fact existing around us, and if it’s something ordinary, why not follow the same path and gain benefits. 


The last reason is the target audience. Yes, in modern times there is still growing number of women who read comics, BUT still the great majority of readers are men. It has always been, and stays for now up, trade running around guys. This is them for whom artist work so hard on characters details, to make them ideal for the viewer. It’s supposed to be something they will love and want to see more, and don’t tell me that looking at very attractive women, running in skimpy clothes and fighting the enemies isn’t something they wouldn’t like too see. As Scott McCloud said in his book “Comics need to appeal to basic human needs and desires – offering a view of the world worth returning to”. This is the most important factor, shaping your final designs for characters – target audience. 



 Conclusion


Those research gave me the whole reasonable explanation of creating characters for comics and explained that all the aspects are dictated by society, history, breaking revolutions, and current trends. As sexual knowledge and confidence started growing, comic characters, considered as ideal, started to change their appearance. Modern models of beauty and confidence are portrayed as very attractive women who feel confident about herself and her body, and that’s why they don’t avoid skimpy costumes. 



Reference books: 

Scott McCloud; Reinventing Comics: How Imagination and Technology are Revolutionizing an Art Form; Harper Collins; 2000; ISBN 0-06-095350-0
Tim Pilcher; Erotic Comics 2: A Graphic History from the Liberated ‘70s to the Internet; Abrams ComicArts; 2009; ISBN 978-0-8109-7277-3
Les Daniels, Chip Kidd, Geoff Spear; The Golden Age of DC Comics: 365 Days; New York ; Harry N. Abrams; 2004; ISBN 0-8109-4969-5
Marvel Comics;Marvel Firsts: The 1970s Volume ; Marvel; 2012, ISBN 0785163808
Bill Everett, Joe Simon, Will Harr , Otto Binder;Marvel Firsts: WWII Super Heroes; Marvel; 2013, ISBN 0785167919


 

 



No comments:

Post a Comment